Media OutReach

2017-09-13 10:00

CUHK Business School Research Reveals How Cultural Background Affects Chinese Immigrants' Overseas Property Investments

HONG KONG, CHINA - Media OutReach - September 13, 2017 - Our world is becoming flat, and moving abroad for better opportunities is increasingly common for people. However, when people choose to move to another country, will they give up their own cultural identities and thus assimilate into one single culture in the new country, or will they remain their own culture traits by congregating together as a way of finding support in a new land?

 

The answer is the latter, according to a study conducted by Prof. Maggie Rong Hu, an assistant professor from the School of Hotel and Tourism Management and Department of Finance of the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) Business School and her collaborator Adrian D. Lee from the University of Technology Sydney. The study indicates that Sydney's newcomers are more likely to choose properties located in neighborhoods that are more culturally similar to their own culture of origin. They are also willing to pay a price premium for properties in locations with shorter cultural distance.

 

And among those newcomers, people from East Asia, particularly Chinese, are most likely to choose to live in a community, which is closer to their culture of origin and more willing to pay higher prices for houses in such neighborhoods.

 

"In our study, we find that an individual's cultural background is indeed an important factor on housing prices," says Prof. Hu.

 

According to Prof. Hu, globalization promotes the integration of societies and has provided millions of people with new opportunities. As a result, megacities with culturally diverse residents, such as Sydney, London, Los Angeles and Toronto, are becoming the new norm, yet little is known about how the interaction between these people and their host country's culture affects their personal and financial decisions, particularly in housing markets.

 

As such, their working paper "Melting Pot or Salad Bowl: Cultural Distance and Housing Investments" examined whether the cultural background of property investors and cultural differences of the neighborhoods influence their housing buying decisions, in terms of location and price.

 

In the paper, the 'melting pot' metaphor describes the fusion of various religious sects, nationalities, and ethnic groups into one distinct people, while 'salad bowl' describes different ethnic groups, rather than assimilating, retain and coexist in their separate identities, just like the different ingredients in a salad.

 

"We would like to find out in a city with diverse culture, whether the 'melting pot' theory dominants or the 'salad bowl' analogy holds true. In other words, whether the different ingredients are all mixed together to make one dish or each ingredient also retains its own characteristics in the bowl," she says.

 

The Study

For the purpose of the study, the researchers targeted Sydney, Australia's largest and most culturally diverse city, where immigrants have made up a large component of its population. According to the statistics from 2011 Australian Bureau of Statistics Census, 57 percent of Sydney urban respondents are non-Australian or British origins.

 

The study looked at individual housing transaction data of the Sydney Metropolitan Area from 2006 to 2013 from Australian Property Monitors, one of the Australia's leading national suppliers of online property price information to banks, financial markets, professional real estate agents and consumers. The dataset includes the transaction price, transaction date, property address, buyer and seller names, and relevant housing characteristics.

 

In addition, the researchers also utilized the data in 2006 and 2011 from the Australian Bureau of Statistics Census, namely the demographics of a suburb, to examine the ethnic composition in Sydney. The data shows that Sydney's top five ethnicity groups in 2011 are Australian, Chinese, Irish, Italian and Arabic.

 

Then, they introduced a term 'culture distance' to gauge the cultural difference between a housing buyer's culture of origin and the culture of neighborhood of a property. They calculated the cultural distance by adopting the six-dimension culture framework introduced by Professor Geert Hofstede, which is widely used in social science research.

 

In this framework, a score on the scale of 0 to 100 is assigned to each country along six dimensions: uncertainty avoidance, individualism, power distance, masculinity, long-term orientation and indulgence.

 

For example, Australia and China differ significantly on several dimensions, particularly on individualism and long-term orientation (see the diagram), according to Hofstede (2001).

 

Using a complex mathematical formula, the researchers reveal that the average cultural distance score over the entire sample is 1.99. Naturally, Australian investors have the lowest average cultural distance score of 1.35 across all ethnic groups. The average cultural distance score for Chinese homebuyers is 2.50. The higher the score on the cultural distance measure, the greater the cultural difference between a buyer and a neighborhood.

 

So how does cultural distance between the homebuyers and the neighborhood influence home buying decisions?

 

Cultural Distance Sensitivity

As expected, the study finds that cultural distance is an important determinant of property investors' location choice and transaction price.

 

To be specific, housing buyers are more likely to choose properties located in neighborhoods that are more culturally similar to their own culture of origin. And they are more willing to pay a higher price for properties in locations with shorter cultural distance.

 

In other words, there is a negative relationship between cultural distance and housing price. The greater the cultural distance between a homebuyer and a neighborhood, the lower the housing price is in the transaction.

 

According to the study, if the cultural distance between a homebuyer and the suburb decreased by 1 unit, which is approximately the difference between the average Australian and average Chinese property buyers' cultural distance in the sample, housing price rises by 1.1 percent or AUD$7,382.

 

Asians and Home Culture Preference

What's more interesting, the study reveals that home investors from different ethnic groups display varying degrees of home culture preference.

 

"Investors from Asia display a greater degree of home culture preference, compared with European and Australian buyers. Particularly, Chinese are most likely to pay higher prices for houses in neighborhoods which are closer to Chinese culture," Prof. Hu points out.

 

The study shows that if the cultural distance between an Asian property investor and the neighborhood decreased by 1 unit, the housing price increase about 2 to 4 percent, whereas the effect is only about 1.3 percent for Europe housing investors.

 

Why is that the case? According to Prof. Hu, people from Asian countries, such as China, India, Malaysia, The Philippines and Vietnam, are more recent migrants into Australia, and thus have stronger cultural bonds with their countries of origin, and may display stronger home culture preference.

 

However, Europeans came to Australia relatively earlier compared with Asian immigrants and their cultural difference is relatively smaller, so they are better adapted to the local Australian society and their ties to their countries of origin are weaker.

 

"Cultural distance sensitivity or home culture preference is weaker for more established ethnic groups than recent migrants," says Prof. Hu.

 

It is worth noting that China has become one of the top sources of immigrants to Australia in recent years and there is a huge new wave of Chinese investment into the Australian property market. Their appetite for the country's properties grows quickly.

 

According to The New York Times, Chinese investment in Australian real estate has increased at least tenfold since 2010; Chinese investors have purchased up to half the new apartments in downtown Sydney.

 

Policy Implications

As the study suggests homebuyers are willing to pay a premium for culture proximity, Prof. Hu believes that it has important policy implications on social diversity and urban planning.

 

Recognition of foreign migrant's inherent desire for cultural preservation is the first step towards a better understanding of foreign migrants and local communities, according to her.

 

"Awareness and respect for the housing investment preference of different ethnic groups would facilitate efficient urban planning," she says.

 

"We document the natural occurrence of cultural and racial segregation through individuals' housing investment decisions in Sydney. And we believe that a similar phenomenon could be observed in other migrant cities with diverse culture, such as San Francisco, Toronto or Vancouver," Prof. Hu concludes.

 

Reference:

Hu, Maggie Rong and Lee, Adrian D., Melting Pot or Salad Bowl: Cultural Distance and Housing Investments (August 31, 2017). 28th Australasian Finance and Banking Conference.

 

This article was first published in the China Business Knowledge (CBK) website by CUHK Business School: https://goo.gl/mY7Vap.

 

About CUHK Business School

CUHK Business School comprises two schools -- Accountancy and Hotel and Tourism Management -- and four departments -- Decision Sciences and Managerial Economics, Finance, Management and Marketing. Established in Hong Kong in 1963, it is the first business school to offer BBA, MBA and Executive MBA programs in the region. Today, the School offers 8 undergraduate programs and 13 graduate programs including MBA, EMBA, Master, MSc, MPhil and PhD.

 

In the Financial Times Global MBA Ranking 2017, CUHK MBA is ranked 36th. In FT's 2016 EMBA ranking, CUHK EMBA is ranked 37th in the world. CUHK Business School has the largest number of business alumni (32,000+) in Hong Kong - many of whom are key business leaders. The School currently has about 4,400 undergraduate and postgraduate students and Professor Kalok Chan is the Dean of CUHK Business School.

 

More information is available at: http://www.bschool.cuhk.edu.hk or by connecting with CUHK Business School on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/cuhkbschool and LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/school/3923680/.

 

About China Business Knowledge (CBK)

CBK is a portal belonging to the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) Business School which provides easy access to the China-related research conducted at CUHK Business School. Through feature articles, mini case studies, discussions and a research paper database, CBK aim to narrow the knowledge gap between China and the rest of the world, providing in-depth knowledge and practical tips about doing business in China. Free content is available at http://www.bschool.cuhk.edu.hk/faculty/cbk/index.aspx or by connecting with CBK@CUHK on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/CBKCUHK, Twitter: https://twitter.com/CBK_CUHK and LinkedIn: http://linkd.in/1B8cGdU.

 



source: CUHK Business School

【養心安神】黃芪當歸元肉雞湯治心悸

人氣文章
財經新聞
評論
專題
生活副刊
DIVA 品味派
最近7天
最近30天
論盡中港台 . 岑逸飛
何來君堯「殺無赦」? 67
鬆一鬆 . 通通
【心理測試】你最不想坐哪個位置?測你的壓力有多大!
暢所欲妍 . 屈穎妍
「大鑊」,學霸! 25 新文章
香港街頭美食
【2017月餅大比拼】編輯部評選!奶皇之最+茶香推介+中秋禮盒
政是有心 . 余君雋
泛民建制,都是豬一樣的對手 27
食療新意思 . 陳沛思
【健脾祛濕】紅豆粟米紅蘿蔔瘦肉湯
陶冬天下 . 陶冬
聯儲開始退出QE了,然後呢......
抵玩自助遊
$3,700 成都玩到稻城 丹巴遊藏寨美人谷
我要退休 . 羅國森、曾智華
盧炳松的退休舞台
政經頑石不低頭 . 石鏡泉
縮表後 市場怎樣走?
我家私房菜 . 韋太
【街頭小食】煎釀虎皮尖椒
欣欣食乜嘢 . 曾欣欣
【保肝護腦】4個番茄解酒精的「毒」
葉劉的地球儀 . 葉劉淑儀
應付校園播「獨」 需立法更需對話 9 新文章
念力•氣功 . 趙婉君 NEW
念力是有用的,由末期肝癌到自癒 1
言歸政傳 . Jenny Yin
九西補選大混戰 鄭泳舜出線阿基想出戰 6
看透生死 . 吳思源
臨終前, 這簡單的五句話足以令人安慰
玄來更精彩 . 黃美雲
女人的美麗誤會 1
形象UP! . 藍婷
【甚麼顏色最適合你?】簡單測試 找出你的穿衣風格 1
打工秘笈
【遲到就扣半日假!】老細有無觸犯法例?
第一桶金 . 方元
向閒置土地徵稅 迫地產商快建屋 2
暢所欲妍 . 屈穎妍
忘國癮君子 230
Bella vita 美好生活 . 葉子僑 Bella
【情緒篇】芬蘭的精神病療法 不食藥也能康復! 3
Green Monday . 楊大偉
「真‧邪惡」芝士!美食背後你所不知的商業秘密 4
鬆一鬆 . 通通
【心理測試】你最不想坐哪個位置?測你的壓力有多大!
看透生死 . 吳思源
在教堂舉行葬禮,你能接受嗎? 63
政是有心 . 余君雋
往死者傷口撒鹽 有何資格做教師? 68
盛衰關鍵 . 林奮強
【禍延3代的房屋問題】撫心自問 Is This Right? 3
玄來更精彩 . 黃美雲
【江湖上的傳說】鬼節禁忌 你要知 4
我做Marketing . Michael & Derek
【你所不知道的強大作用】點解開會一定要帶本簿? 4
香港街頭美食
【2017月餅大比拼】編輯部評選!奶皇之最+茶香推介+中秋禮盒
欣欣食乜嘢 . 曾欣欣
【果仁高脂要戒口?】超級食物杏仁 可助清除壞膽固醇 2
打工秘笈
【「炒魷」候選人】盤點職場8種高危被炒員工 4
玩樂好去處
【地球資源已耗盡】「潛航凶間」7大鬼屋體驗!潛入海底廢棄船大揭秘 4
創業兵團
專訪GoGoVan創辦人林凱源 住木屋的78億CEO 1
我家私房菜 . 韋太
【養顏抗衰老】蛋白杏仁茶 1
我要退休 . 羅國森、曾智華
退休—快樂地花錢 1
台灣熱話 . 姚超文
【台灣政壇怪現象】馬英九被400多宗官司纏身? 5
健康解「迷」
營養師教你 這樣吃BUFFET不會肥! 4
星座命理
【驅邪小法寶】鬼節都唔驚! 4
抵玩自助遊
$8200 去西藏 睇冰川 遊聖湖 1
產品簡介

【etnet健康好人生】趙頌茹專訪 即睇即答 賞CANVAS 100%澳洲有機香薰油舒緩套裝

【DIVA品味派】賞睇《美國特工》

【得獎名單】【DIVA 品味派】賞「Cine Italiano! - 香港意大利電影週」戲票